Author Topic: Suggestions regarding keyboards  (Read 4344 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

AnupamEnosh

  • Guest
Suggestions regarding keyboards
« on: July 12, 2019, 12:38:38 PM »
Hi,
I've been active on the forum for some time, since I got hands on my E453. But it is like almost two year old now. I feel that I am done with this keyboard, the keys are too rough and it is noticeable whenever I use some other brand's keyboard, so I need to get myself a better keyboard for primary usage. I have a budget cap of 1000$ right now. I have a few questions which I need to know before I decide something :

1.) Which keyboards from Yamaha can I consider for making youtube covers, as well as live stage performances ?

2.) Should it be an arranger or a synthesizer, the one that provides me with a professional level sound quality (output) of different instrument voices ?

3.) Also, what are the hassles or gaps that would be created when I move from an arranger to a synthesizer like MX-61 ? Do S series keyboards provide better sound output than synthesizers like MX-61, or is it vice versa ?

4.) Is MX-61 an expandable synthesizer or not ? Can I add new patches/loops to it, or do I need to increase my budget to get an expandable synthesizer from Yamaha ? Please mention the model names.

5.) I'm from India, here we have Indian Classical music and a wide variety of Indian percussion/stringed instruments, with their roots diving deep into the existing music industry here. So are there some good options in Yamaha to fulfill these, or do I need to move out to some other brands like Roland, Korg etc ?

I'm confused because in this era, we have a mega array of keyboards from different brands offering distinct features, and certainly not every keyboard can fulfill the demands of a player.
 

SeaGtGruff

  • Guest
Re: Suggestions regarding keyboards
« Reply #1 on: July 13, 2019, 08:48:11 AM »
1.) Which keyboards from Yamaha can I consider for making youtube covers, as well as live stage performances ?

I'd think you can consider arrangers like Genos, Tyros, PSR-S, or other high-level PSR models (such as PSR-A). And you can also consider synths, as well as digital pianos, depending on what you're looking for as far as features, portability, etc.

Quote
2.) Should it be an arranger or a synthesizer, the one that provides me with a professional level sound quality (output) of different instrument voices ?

That's up to you. If you make heavy use of styles while performing, then you'll probably want an arranger. But if you don't use styles and want something that gives you more control over the sounds while you're playing live, then you'll probably want a synth.

Quote
3.) Also, what are the hassles or gaps that would be created when I move from an arranger to a synthesizer like MX-61 ? Do S series keyboards provide better sound output than synthesizers like MX-61, or is it vice versa ?

The biggest gap when going from an arranger to a synth will be the lack of styles or auto accompaniments. I'd think the quality of the sound would depend more on the model than on whether it's an arranger or a synth.

Quote
4.) Is MX-61 an expandable synthesizer or not ? Can I add new patches/loops to it, or do I need to increase my budget to get an expandable synthesizer from Yamaha ? Please mention the model names.

No, the MX line is not expandable in the sense of being able to load new wave samples to it as you can do with the MOXF and MODX lines. However, you can still load or create new voices from the existing elements (wave samples), by mixing different ones together or by changing their sound parameters (similar to how you can customize voices on the PSR-E453, but to a much greater extent). Or you can simply customize the preset voices, or layer them together however you wish-- up to 16 at once, called a "performance." There are some free performance packs available, plus software for creating voices and performances. (The tiny LCD screen and function menu make it difficult to do those things on the synth itself, so the software is extremely useful because it lets you do it on a computer.)

Note that the MX can also use a free iPad app from Yamaha which lets you create and play FM synth voices, and you can certainly play other iPad soft synths with it as well. (For that matter, you can do this with your PSR-E453 as well.)

If the MX synths are not flexible enough for you, you might consider one of the MODX synths, or perhaps an older MOXF, MOX, or MO synth. Of course, if cost is not an issue, then go for the Montage or Motif! :)

Frankly, you first need to decide whether you'd be happiest with an arranger so you can play auto accompaniments. But another possibility might be to get one of each-- one of the PSR-S arrangers, plus the MX49 Mk2 synth (because it's the lowest-priced one yet has all the same features of the MX61 and MX88).

Quote
5.) I'm from India, here we have Indian Classical music and a wide variety of Indian percussion/stringed instruments, with their roots diving deep into the existing music industry here. So are there some good options in Yamaha to fulfill these, or do I need to move out to some other brands like Roland, Korg etc ?

Have you looked at the higher PSR-A models, such as the PSR-A3000? I don't think you'd be happy with the lower PSR-A models, such as the PSR-A350.
 

AnupamEnosh

  • Guest
Re: Suggestions regarding keyboards
« Reply #2 on: July 13, 2019, 02:39:42 PM »
Thanks for the inputs Sir.
Seems like Yamaha has no compatible keyboards for me, in the range of 1000$. MX-61 was my preference untill I came to know it has no expandibility options.
PSR S-series keyboards are too big to carry (for me atleast) and frankly speaking I don't find its sounds matching my expectations.
MO, MOX, MOXF keyboards are also not available here.
Also PSR A series boards are not launched in India, so it will not be affordable for me to import it to my country, since Yamaha India doesn't provide service to imported (not launched in the country) keyboards.
I would have to move to Roland, Korg as they have some good offerings in this range, XPS-30, Kross 2, Krome Ex etc.. And a lot of support for Roland for expandibility is available on online platforms.. 🙂
 

SeaGtGruff

  • Guest
Re: Suggestions regarding keyboards
« Reply #3 on: July 13, 2019, 03:17:50 PM »
Whatever you decide on, I do hope you have the opportunity to try it out in a store first, to be sure the feel of the keybed will be sufficient for you, and of course that it sounds satisfactory. :)